Customer Reviews
If you don't have N-wireless networking or
desire a usb port, get the cheaper model
First let me say I own a Roku and LOVE it! NetFlix and Roku are a
marriage made in heaven as far as I'm concerned, and they are saving me
tons of money and treks to the video store. The picture, ease of use,
wireless capabilities, quality of video content... everything is great!
But as a consumer it's important to understand the differences
between the 3 Roku offerings so you can make an informed decision on
your purchase. It does seem odd that Roku has simply not put out one
device at one price for everyone with all the bells and whistles, but
for now, you have to choose one... based upon your needs and budget.
THE DIFFERENCES IN ROKU PLAYERS:
Roku HD Player is capable of wired or wireless hook-up, but not at
the fastest speed available from a 'N' wireless network. HD content
streams to this device flawlessly (if the content is available and your
home network is sending a proper signal), despite not being 'N' network
ready.
That being said, Roku came out with Roku HD-XR Player which WILL
stream the fastest 'N' network standard, provided the rest of your home
network is also working with the same standard. That being said, this
device is not at all necessary if you don't have all the devices on your
home network using the 'N' standard, because the speed will only go as
fast as the device with the slowest connection which is probably the 'B
or G' standard.
The third device is available on Roku's website. Roku SD, which
streams in standard definition, will not stream HD content, isn't
capable of surround sound audio like the other two and does not have a
HDMI connection. It only supports the red/yellow/white (composite video
and audio) connections, but it will connect wirelessly or can be
hardwired to the internet, working on a 'B or G' network. The Roku SD is
about twenty bucks less than the Roku HD and , so again, consider your
needs before buying. **Anyone with a standard def TV and who doesn't
plan to upgrade to an HDTV with HDMI ports any time soon, would probably
want this version.
The Roku HD-XR Player is a jump up from the HD model in wireless
capabilities. All the Roku offerings will give you years of enjoyment by
boosting your NetFlix subscription, streaming Amazon On Demand media
and boosting your viewing library. What the HD-XR has that the others
don't: 'N' network capabilities and 1 USB port for firmware upgrades and
possibly, other media hook-ups via USB, but at this time Roku doesn't
even bring up the USB on their website so I tend to wonder about this
being a selling point. Is it worth the extra cost? Only you know the
answer to that question.
MY CONCLUSION:
The quality of the streaming video on my 'G' network is perfect;
standard and HD content, via my Roku HD, but since I don't have a 'N'
network, nor do I expect I will in the near future, I saved myself a bit
of money and didn't buy this one.
The only reason I give this product 4 versus 5 stars is because of
the price bump for the ability to use an 'N' wireless network when
frankly I believe it should be considered a standard feature, not an
extra. The USB port, whatever it's used for, should also be standard on
all models. Again, it would be wonderful to have one Roku with all the
potential connections and wireless ability, and perhaps in the future
there will be, but for now you need to consider these three: Roku SD,
Roku HD and Roku HD-XR.
To may your own informed choice, evaluate your needs and buy
accordingly. While the Roku products are not media storage devices or
DVR's, they can give you a tremendous boost in your enjoyment of NetFlix
and expand your viewing library.
ROKU HD-XR PLAYER SPECIFICATIONS (per the Roku website):
*Note the USB port isn't even listed as a feature.
Networking
Wi-Fi (802.11N/B/G "dual-band") with WEP, WPA, and WPA2 support
10/100 Ethernet (RJ-45)
Video Outputs
Composite video (480i)
S-Video (480i)
Component video (Y/Pb/Pr - 720p/480p)
HDMI (720p/480p)
Video Modes
16:9 High Definition (HD)
16:9 anamorphic
4:3 standard
Audio Output
Stereo (L/R RCA)
Digital Optical (Toslink - Stereo/Surround)
Digital over HDMI (Stereo/Surround)
Remote Control
NEC protocol, supported by various universal remotes
Power Input
5V, 2.5A provided by included AC adapter
Power Consumption
6 watts peak, 4 watts in standby
Size
5 x 5 x 1.75 inches (130 x 130 x 41 mm)
Weight
11 oz (300 grams)
You'll have to read this to believe it
The Roku HD-XR is fantastic. Even if you only have Wirless-G, what
you see on screen still looks like a million bucks, and is truly HD,
even if you have na HD TV or not. It's only actually 720P, and not
1080p, but unless you're using a large TV over 32", you'd never even
notice anyway. Regardless, it still looks fantastic.
Before I gush over the features, however, I MUST tell you about the
experience I had with getting it connected:
First, it took less than 5 minutes to pull it out of the box to
watching movies on NetFlix. It's astonishingly no-brainer, and I'm dead
serious when I say that. If you also have an internet-connected
wireless laptop sitting in your lap during setup, drop the
out-of-the-box-to-watching-movies time to 3 minutes.
Now this is where this little device knocked my socks off: I'm a
computer network engineer, and I do not have a simple wireless internet
setup in my house. I have a very complex enterprise network set up,
consisting of servers and workstations, cabled and wireless, and
connecting wirelessly to my network insfrastructure is required to make
use of my internet proxy server. This is just like the same setup you
find in corporate offices.
So to make a long story short, I was worried that the Roku would not
be able to make use of my complex internet proxy server for internet
access and that I'd have to return it. I thought the box would be to
"dumb", or would not have the required configuration menus to make use
of such complex networking architecture. If you know what internet
proxy servers are, then you know exactly what I'm talking about.
Imagine my surprise when I entered my network wireless security
information (so it could connect to SOMETHING at least), when it also
automatically found my proxy server and AUTOMATICALLY CONFIGURED ITSELF
to make use of it. All 3 of the Roku's on-screen indicators all lit up
green and BAM! - I was punching right into our NetFlix queue, our queued
movies already waiting to be watched. WOW! And I mean WOW!!! This
little gizmo has the ability to hunt down proxy servers on local area
networks and make use of them AUTOMATICALLY without further
configuration! Did I say WOW!!!!???
Oh, and by the way: My wireless network is pumped through a
Wireless-G LinkSys Access Point (WAP), which is what the Roku is talking
to for connection t my network. And it works GREAT. So for the
reviewer who said that it won't talk through LinkSys hardware - sorry,
not true.
VERY happy with this device. Embarrassingly close to euphoric, in
fact, simply because of it's configuration and connectivity capabilities
alone! The fact that it connected so quickly and so incredibly on my
network is reason enough for me to own this thing. Let alone how cool
it is to actually use, watch and enjoy, the very reason you get one in
the first place!
However, I simply must also add these additional review details:
The box itself is very small, the size of a small jewelry box, and
blended right in with my home theater system. It's even pleasing to the
eye to some degree, not the typical mess of cables you'd expect. It
takes up virtually no shelf space and only has two cables connected to
it if you're using wireless and HDMI: the HDMI cable itself and the
power cord. That's it. The remote control itself is VERY small, be
careful, it will slip down between couch cusions VERY easily. But it's
very nice looking and very stupid-simple to operate, having only a few
buttons for menu and playback control. The simplicity of the thing is
so beautiful compared to the typical "slap a million buttons on it for
cool factor" we're inundated with these days that I'm darned close to
taking the thing out to dinner and a movie.
The device is extremely simple to use, no tech savvy-ness required.
You will absolutely LOVE the simplicity of it. It is so amazingly
simple that I'm going to risk sounding like an idiot by calling it an
engineering masterpiece. And trust me when I say that I know
technology. As much as I like to go full-blown geek on most things,
this device is so refreshingly simple that I'm surprised at such a
device can be so simple. I'm also surprised at myself for being so
thrilled with it.
The included directions that come with it are incredibly simple.
However, the device is so simple to hook up and use, I'd offer that the
included quick-start instructions aren't even necessary.
My Roku is hooked up to a 52" Samsung HDTV at 1080p. The picture
quality of the streamed content over the Roku is very impressive for a
720P device streaming compressed internet media content. Please
understand that compression is required for internet streaming, and that
you will notice some fuzz in the picture, especially if you have a big
HDTV. That's the nature of internt streaming, and is not because of any
shortcoming of the Roku product itself.
Even though the Roku has true HD mode, do not expect crystal clear
"HD" content - remember, this device hooks up to ANY TV, not just HD.
Imagine slightly better quality regualr TV on a giant screen. That's
how it is watching a Roku on an HDTV, especially a big one, even with
the Roku's HD display feature enabled. The menus are crystal clear in
HD - the actual streaming media content you'll be watching will not be,
it's like watching slightly enhanced regualr TV, at least on large TVs.
On smaller TVs, 32" and smaller, it will look fantastic.
And the question many of you are wodnering: What if you will be
using the Roku simultaneously with other computes or devices in your
home on the same internet conenction? Simple: use common sense.
You'll have no problems if all you're doing is email and web browsing
while watching thigns on the Roku box. Online gaming and downloading
giant files, however, might cause the Roku to kick picture quality down
or pause for buffering or even stop it dead in its tracks altogether. I
have had no problems whatsoever so far, but I make sure to keep
computer use to "light duty" while watching content over the Roku. Use a
little common sense and you'll have no problems. Surprisingly, it does
a lot better than I thought it would.
Critical: for wireless use, the Roku needs to be at Wireless-G or
higher. If you have a PDA or older laptop that only does Wireless-A or
B, and your internet router is in mixed mode (allows A, B, G and N),
most wireless routers/access points will kick down in speed to match the
slowest device talking to it. This will basically stop the Roku dead
in its tracks by pretty much dropping it's access to the itnernet down
to virtually nothing. Don't use old slow wireless-A/B products if
you're using your Roku wirelessly.
The most economical entertainment under the sun: NetFlix is only
$10 a month, but you must understand that the Roku will only play the
movies that NetFlix has made available in their "watch now" category,
and that category really isn't all that impressive. Most NetFlix titles
are still DVD-by-mail-only, so their entire catolog is not available to
the Roku player. However, Amazon's On-Demand service, though it is
pay-per-view and much more expensive at 1-3$ per movie viewing, has over
45,000 titles you can watch immediately on the Roku. Either way you
go, this is an incredible entertainment system. As for me personally,
we're subscribed to NetFlix and watch the occasional Amazon On-Demand
title when a new release comes out we want to see. All total, we're
probably spending no more than $20 a month to watch what we want to
watch and when we want to watch it. This is at about 25-30% of a normal
cable bill, and all while providing convenience, content and
flexibility that cable or satellite can't even (currently) dream of.
You just can't beat it.
This is how all cable and satellite service content will eventually
be delivered. Until then, you get it all right now with the Roku.
And if you don't have Wireless-N in your home yet, and you're
thinking about saving $10 and getting the lesser model, just get this
one - you're going to soon have Wireless-N in your home anyway, so get
it right the first time. Otherwise you'll just end up buying this model
later anyway.
Also, this Roku box, when first plugged in, will download an update
and then reboot itself. Afterwards, you will see the main menu for the
first time and be pleasantly surprised to find that not only are NetFlix
and Amazon On-Demand available to the Roku, but also several other
music and video streaming services, such as Pandora, a NBL (baseball)
streaming service, and several other trial services.
All "surprises" with this box were pleasant, no bad experiences,
failures or complaints whatsoever.
I want to finish this review with the following statement: This by
far - dead serious - the best $130 I have ever spent in my life. Bang
for buck, I have never seen anything provide such incredible
high-quality entertainment in such a well-engineered way in such an
attractive, small, easy-to-use package. If you ever wanted to see magic
in a little box, thsi is the product. Not often you get to see cool
things like this come along, but here's a real winner of an example.
"Roku" is misnamed. It should be "Kudos".
A great new toy
I am really enjoying my new Roku XR. The setup was extremely easy
and intuitive. I am running the ROKU XR wirelessly off of an N-Router
(Trendnet 633) located on the other side of the house. I am getting "4
dots and HD" (best quality) with no interuptions in play.
My only complaint is that I have to go to Netflix and enter movies I
want to watch on the Netflix Instant Queue before the Roku XR will play
the movie. So basically, I have to go to my computer, find my TV shows
or movies, enter them into the Instant Queue on the computer then goto
the ROKU and my selections will be available to watch. I really wish I
could scan for movies and shows thru the ROKU.
Other than that, the setup and playback quality is excellent using
HDMI. Recommended :)